André Picard, the medical reporter at the
Globe and Mail, has a wonderful article today:
Forget poppies – vets deserve flu vaccine. Excerpt:
Public-health officials tell us that relegating older people to the bottom of the priority is not ageism but good science.
But all evidence requires an element of interpretation and all public policies involve tough choices.
There are data that suggest that older people – those born prior to 1957 – have some immunity to H1N1 because most of the flu strains that circulated between 1918 and 1957 were of the H1N1 variety, cousins to the current pandemic strain.
Practically, this means that older people have a lesser risk of contracting H1N1.
But the cold, hard data on hospitalizations and deaths also tell us that, when seniors contract H1N1, they have the highest rate of hospitalization and death.
Yet, we hear incessantly that this pandemic strain of influenza is a public-health priority because of the risk it poses to children and young adults. In these groups, flu deaths are normally very rare and now they are merely rare.
The unspoken but implied calculus here is that the death of a senior is less of a tragedy than the death of a child or an adult in the “prime” of his or her life.
We see this attitude in our influenza policies writ large. Governments and public-health authorities have pulled out all the stops in response to H1N1. This may or may not be appropriate.
What is unquestionable is that we pay far too little attention to seasonal flu, the run-of-the-mill disease that comes round each winter, strikes down 4,000 to 8,000 people and results in the hospitalization of tens of thousands more.
Let's be frank: We treat this recurring public-health disaster with casual indifference because deaths and severe illness occur almost exclusively in older people.
When nursing homes are being decimated by influenza, when thousands of grandmas and grandpas are hospitalized with “regular” life-threatening flu, we don't see almost daily press conferences by the Minister of Health, full-page newspaper ads urging vaccination, unprecedented mobilization of public health and hysteria.
We see a collective shrug of the shoulders.
Picard has put his finger on a very, very big problem: the contempt of the young for their elders.
As North America's baby boomers hit 65, a generation that has always considered itself the center of the world will find itself dismissed--or simply regarded as a tiresome and expensive problem. I hope the boomers fight back.
Recent Comments